A creditor who files a claim against a Montana estate has not yet been paid. The personal representative must decide whether to allow or dispute it, and a missed step by either side can settle the outcome.
How a personal representative responds to a claim
A properly presented claim waits until the personal representative decides. The decision is either an allowance, which puts the claim in line for payment, or a disallowance, which sends the dispute back to the creditor.
Under Mont. Code Ann. 72-3-805, the representative may mail a creditor notice that a timely claim is disallowed. The creditor must then petition the court or start a proceeding within 60 days of the mailing, as long as the notice warns of that deadline.
What silence from the representative means
A representative who never answers a claim has still made a decision under the statute. Failing to mail notice of action within 60 days after the presentation period expires has the effect of a notice of allowance.
A family opening probate with a Missoula probate lawyer should still track the 60-day mark on every claim, because an unanswered claim can become an allowed one. A written response removes that risk.
Counterclaims the estate can deduct
Some creditors owe the estate money as well. When the representative allows such a claim, that debt can come off the payment.
Mont. Code Ann. 72-3-806 lets the representative deduct any counterclaim the estate holds against the claimant, even one that arose from a different transaction. If the counterclaim is larger than the claim, the court enters judgment against the claimant for the excess.
Options for a creditor after a disallowance
A disallowance does not end the matter, because the creditor can still go to court. The statute sets out what follows:
- A creditor who files a petition or starts a proceeding within 60 days of the mailed notice keeps the disallowed claim alive.
- A creditor who waits past 60 days loses the disallowed part of the claim.
- A court may allow all or part of a timely claim on petition from either the representative or the claimant.
Limits on changing a decision
A representative can reverse a decision, but only within limits. An allowance can become a disallowance before payment if the creditor receives notice, and a disallowance can become an allowance until the claim is barred.
A barred claim can be allowed and paid only when the estate is solvent and every affected successor consents. A court order allowing a claim ends the representative’s power to disallow it.
What the executor records for each claim
A representative should keep each claim, notice date, and response in one file. That record shows when each 60-day period began.
A representative who keeps that file from the first claim received is also meeting the executor responsibilities of the role. The file also supports any later accounting to heirs.
How interest builds on allowed claims
The same section that governs disallowance notices provides that an allowed claim earns interest at the legal rate beginning 60 days after the presentation period expires. A contract rate controls instead when the creditor’s contract provides for interest.
An unresolved claim can hold up distributions, which lengthens probate timelines in Montana. Interest keeps growing while the estate waits.
Why planning reduces the burden
Assets held in a living trust pass outside probate, so they don’t go through the same court process as property titled in the decedent’s name. A family that plans ahead has fewer assets in the claims process.
That is the reasoning behind Missoula living trust planning, which places assets in a trust. Assets that stay in the decedent’s name still pass through probate.
An older adult’s will, trust, and power of attorney should name the same assets and people, which is the starting point for Missoula elder law planning. A mismatch between them leaves a court or a family to sort out the conflict after the owner’s death.
Asset protection planning should begin before a care need arises, and the first step in Missoula asset protection is listing the assets the plan would cover. A list of titles shows how each asset would pass.
Probate matters that begin with creditor claims
Kai Puhrmann ran his own estate planning practice before moving into estate work at the firm. He also worked with the Montana Innocence Project. Our attorneys at Montana Elder Law, Inc. handle Montana probate matters for families.
Tracking each claim from arrival to resolution
A tracking sheet needs the date each claim arrived, the date of the response, and the last day for the creditor to petition. Those dates show which claims are still open. A family beginning probate in western Montana can inquire with a Missoula probate lawyer to set up that tracking sheet. The first claim sets the first date.